Saturday, November 21, 2026

"Mr. Mercedes" Years Two and Three

Spoilers for the first season ahead.


I knew that the second and third seasons of "Mr. Mercedes" weren't going to be as good as the first, but there's something to be said for the pleasures of sticking with a solid, unexceptional drama with some decent bones, even if it's a step down from what it was before.  


Based on the second and third books in Stephen King's trilogy about detective Bill Hodges, these two seasons of "Mr. Mercedes" run into adaptation troubles almost immediately.  I haven't read the books, but it's apparent that the ordering was switched.  The second season is based on the third book, which features the villain Brady Hartsfield again, and the third is based on the second book, where we have a new pair of villains with a similar dynamic to Brady and his mother in the first season.  I suspect that this was done to keep Harry Treadaway in the cast for the second season, though the show's creators have a heck of a time giving him things to do as the secondary protagonist.  Final warnings for spoilers here.  This is because Brady Hartsfield is in a coma for nearly the entire season, and nearly all the scenes from his POV stick him on a separate set representing his mind, with hardly anyone to play off of, mostly watching the action play out around him.  It mostly works, but his storyline isn't nearly as good as it was in the first season. 


The second season also takes a turn into supernatural territory, with Brady gaining various impossible mental abilities thanks to being experimented on by an unscrupulous doctor, Felix Babineau (Jack Huston).  The mystery this year involves various people around Brady coming to harm, but Bill Hodges can't tie the incidents to Brady because he's in a vegetative state by all appearances.  There's much less source material available to fill the ten episode season, so a great deal of the running time is taken up with all of the secondary characters trying to come to terms with the events of the first season.  Holly and Bill have started their own private investigation business, Finders Keepers, but we also check in with Jerome, Lou, Ida, and Bill's ex-wife Donna (Nancy Travis), to varying degrees of success.  A new ADA character, Antonio Montez (Maximiliano Hernández) seems to hang around the hospital to get into regular arguments with Bill and Babineau, but otherwise the season mostly feels like it's killing time until the last two episodes finally allow a few confrontations to happen.


The third season is more interesting.  A lot of elements feel like they're repeating the successful bits of the first season, but the new additions to the cast are excellent.  A significant amount of time involves Lou having run afoul of the law, and her lawyer, Ronald Finkelstein, is played by Brett Gelman, and the colorful judge at her trial, Bernard Raines, by Glynn Turman.  However, the big mystery of the season involves the murder of a local author, Josh Rothstein (Bruce Dern), by one of his fans, a young man named Morris Bellamy (Gabriel Enert), who is being influenced by his much older lover, Alma Lane (Kate Mulgrew).  A third major POV is provided by a high school student, Pete Saubers (Rarmian Newton), who ends up with the stolen property that Morris and Alma are looking for, and hides it from everyone including his parents (Josh Daugherty, Claire Bronson).  


Bill and Holly get involved in the search for Rothstein's killer, because it turns out that Bill is also a fan of his books, but they spend most of the season trying to help Lou.  Having Brett Gelman and Breeda Wool to play off of makes the lead characters more fun to watch, and it feels like Bill and Holly have more satisfying personal arcs this year.  The court proceedings are utter nonsense from a legal standpoint, but I'm not watching this show for a realistic depiction of the justice system.  My MVP of this season is Kate Mulgrew, who goes way over the top as the nasty, manipulative Alma, but in a very enjoyable way.  Mulgrew really doesn't get enough work, and I was delighted to find her chewing the scenery here with such panache.  Bruce Dern also gets a few good scenes as a pontificating phantom, occasionally appearing to Bill Hodges to remind him of his shortcomings. 


And I'm glad that this is where the show decided to stop.  The end of the third season offers decent resolutions for all the main characters, and they've stretched the source material as far as it can go.  Stephen King is famously not good at endings, and "Mr. Mercedes" probably should have stopped after the first season, but the show ends in a perfectly good place.


---

No comments:

Post a Comment