It was inevitable that "Tales of Dunk and Egg" would be adapted after the success of "Game of Thrones." However, despite taking place in Westeros, "Dunk and Egg," is a very different piece of work, and the adaptation, "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms," follows suit. These are much lower stakes stories that follow one POV throughout - that of low-born "hedge knight" Ser Duncan the Tall (Peter Claffey), who goes on adventures with his squire Egg (Dexter Sol Asell). The first season is six half-hour episodes, which can easily be polished off in a single sitting.
Duncan is the former squire of Ser Arlan (Danny Webb), an obscure, impoverished wanderer, recently deceased. Duncan wants to be a knight, and travels to an inn where he meets a strangely knowledgeable boy named Egg, who wants to be his squire. The two of them decide to enter a tournament at a nearby town, but there are challenging requirements they'll need to fulfill to be able to compete. They come across many characters, both high-born and low, including friendly Ser Steffon (Edward Ashley) and his squire Raymun (Shaun Thomas), the dissolute Ser Manfred (Daniel Monks), who employs prostitutes Beony (Carla Harrison-Hodge) and Rowan (Rowan Robinson), boisterous Ser Lyonel (Daniel Ings), a Dornish puppeteer, Tanselle (Tanzyn Crawford), and the current heir to the Iron Throne, Prince Baelor (Bertie Carvel), his brother Prince Maekar (Sam Spruell), and Maekar's sons Daeron (Henry Ashton) and Aerion (Finn Bennett).
Unlike most "Game of Thrones" characters, Ser Duncan is a fairly straightforward hero with a very traditional hero's arc and a sad, simple backstory. Westeros is as corrupt and brutal as it's always been, and the showrunners delight in showing us the more disgusting side of life before modern plumbing and medicine. However, "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms" is a series where people believe in honor and valor more seriously, and Ser Duncan has the opportunity to prove himself, even if it's not in the way he intended. The first season is short, but manages to set up a few thrilling events, and nicely establish our main characters for further seasons. I like that there's a sense of more epic and consequential stories happening in the background, but these don't really affect Dunk and Egg. The whole season happens in the space of only a few days.
Peter Claffey, a very tall former professional rugby player, and Dexter Sol Ansell, a very small child actor, are a pair I have zero awareness of seeing in anything else, which makes their performances here all the more delightful. Claffley plays Duncan as good-hearted and simpleminded, without being slow-witted, and capable of being intense and formidable when he needs to be. There are some great moments where you can feel him lock in on a goal in a way that's really effective. Ansell is playing the Westerosi version of a smart-aleck kid who is simultaneously young and vulnerable enough to tug on the heartstrings. The two work very well together onscreen, though there's room for improvement. The supporting cast is excellent all around, featuring some solid character actors like Sam Spruell and Daniel Monks making the most of limited screen time.
It's hard not to draw comparisons to "The Mandalorian," not just because of the "Lone Wolf and Cub" character dynamics, but because I worry that HBO will try and make the show bigger than it's designed to be. They've already made that mistake once with "Game of Thrones." "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms" is already in production on its second season, and my hope is that the showrunners will continue to keep it limited in scope. I like that it's a more modest production, without much distracting spectacle, and content to stick to only a few locations. The quality is still very high, with a couple of anachronistic soundtrack choices to distinguish it from the rest of the franchise, but everything is simple enough that seasons can be made more quickly, and present a more immediate and immersive view of Weteros. So far the writing is also sticking very close to George R. R. Martin's source material, which is a plus
I'm keeping my fingers crossed, and looking forward to next season.
---