I was pretty sure I knew what to expect with "Five Star Weekend," the adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's 2023 novel, which I keep seeing described as a "beach read." It's a lighthearted melodrama about five women spending a weekend together in Nantucket, invited by the main character, Hollis (Jennifer Garner), to help keep her mind off the recent death of her husband Matthew (Josh Hamilton). The guests include her childhood friend Tatum (Chloe Sevigny), her college friend Dru-Ann (Regina Hall), her fellow-mom friend Brooke (D'Arcy Carden), and a friend she met through her online influencer work, Gigi (Gemma Chan). Hollis's prickly college-aged daughter Caroline (Harlow Jane), Hollis's old boyfriend Jack (Timothy Olyphant), and a nosy ex-friend, Electra (Judy Greer) are also around to keep things interesting.
I was pleasantly surprised by the show, specifically the performances. I haven't had the best experiences with some of these actresses in other projects, and I'm happy to say that nearly everyone exceeded expectations. Regina Hall was easily my favorite, playing a sports agent in the middle of being cancelled on social media, and way too stubborn to think she did anything wrong. Jennifer Garner was close behind, playing a much more well-rounded version of the stressed-out mom that she usually plays in family comedies. Chan and Sevigny were both a lot funnier onscreen than I've ever seen them - and in completely different ways. I already knew D'Arcy Carden and Judy Greer were going to be a riot, and they were. It was also nice to catch up on the new batch of nepo-kid actors. Harlow Jane's a natural, and West Duchovy as Tatum's daughter Aubrey is also lovely onscreen.
My tolerance for melodrama and "Beaches" style weepiness is not very high, so I appreciate that "Five Star Weekend" kept these elements couched in a lot of humor and a lot of shenanigans. But, crucially, not too many shenanigans. I can easily imagine a much more condensed, feature film version of the same story with broader, raunchier humor, more explosive confrontations, and a lot less nuance. "Five Star Weekend" is absolutely full of all the tropes you'd expect in a show about a group of forty and fifty-something women blowing off steam, but it never felt like any of the characters were being underserved, or any of their problems being treated too flippantly. Infidelity, sexuality, grief, aging, parenting, and major health problems are all in the mix, and handled with grace and care. The only area that feels rather underserved is that romance, which is terribly chaste. And that's a pity, because Timothy Olyphant has never looked better.
I'm not above watching shows like this for the lifestyle vibes and aesthetics. There are some attempts to moderate this, with a few of the guests being money-conscious blue collar and middle class women, but the main character is a food and cooking influencer, so of course the indulgence is everywhere. The show has eight episodes that each correspond with an item on Hollis's fabulous itinerary for the weekend. Fancy meals, shopping and spa trips, gift bags, and new outfits are around every corner. Beauty shots of food are especially plentiful. It's clear that I could never be in close proximity with Hollis for long, because being around her looks positively exhausting, not to mention terrible for my diet. It's easy to sympathize with her though, because being too much is part of her way of deflecting from thornier emotional issues. And it's nice when a show acknowledges this.
My relationship with traditional women's media - the soaps, the Lifetime Original movies, the melodramas and weepies, the rom-coms, and the picturesque travelogues - has had its ups and downs over the years. I still find myself approaching something like "Five Star Weekend" with trepidation, even though there's no reason to. It's a well made series with good talent involved, where the laughs and the poignancy are well balanced. It's certainly wish fulfillment, but self-aware in a good way. I really hope we get more like this, to help rehab the genre's terrible reputation.
A second season is in the works, which hopefully means more dramatic weekends with the ladies to come. Let's hope they can make it a regular thing.
---