I'm frequently left slightly off-balance by Paul Thomas Anderson movies. I enjoy and admire them, because Anderson is one of the best filmmakers currently working, but I'm never quite sure if I get them the way that he means for me to. Are the elements that I take seriously supposed to be funny? Am I missing major themes or ideas that haven't been spelled out for me? Things that are left open to interpretation sometimes make me feel anxious that I'm interpreting them wrong. Everything is connected in "Magnolia," but I'm almost certain that there are connections that I missed somewhere.
The only Paul Thomas Anderson film I don't feel this way towards is "Punch-Drunk Love," and that's because I enjoy it so much that I don't much care if I am missing anything. It is unabashedly a movie romance, filled with big emotions, vibrant colors, indelible images, and grandiose expressions of love. It also stars Adam Sandler, made back in 2002 when Adam Sandler was a movie star known for playing one particular type of aggressive man-child character in his movies. He's playing a variation on that same character in this movie too, but the difference is that in "Punch-Drunk Love," this is a liability. The universe does not reward Barry Egan for his outbursts of violence or his juvenile behavior, until he finds a reason to change his life, and turn his worst habits to his advantage.
The Roger Ebert review of "Punch-Drunk Love" is legendary for Ebert changing his negative opinion of Adam Sandler once he saw Sandler in a role that gave him the ability to play a full-fledged human being. For me, as someone who avoided the early Sandler comedies, it was a signal that Sandler was an actor that I should be paying attention to. It was "Punch-Drunk Love" that made me a fan of his, and Barry Egan is still my favorite of his characters by far. In Barry I could see all the loneliness, frustration, rage, and fear that drove his destructive behavior. And for the first time, I could see and appreciate the sweetness and the wonder mixed in there too. I shared his delight at finding an abandoned harmonium and the loophole in an airline mile giveaway program. I rooted for him when he threw caution to the wind and followed the lovely Lena to Hawaii.
"Punch-Drunk Love" is also one of the most beautiful films of its era, thanks to Anderson and cinematographer Robert Elswit. There's a lot of experimentation going on with light temperature, shape, and silhouette to make the visual contrasts especially bold. There's a very limited color palette and the major colors are all associated with various emotions and characters - Barry is blue and Lena is red. The action is broken up by abstract collages of bright colors, created by Jeremy Blake. Once you start looking, there are stripes and blocks of color all over the place, and they all look amazing. Even the lens flares look gorgeous. The recurring aural motif is Shelly Duvall's kitschy "He Loves Me," from Robert Altman's notorious "Popeye" movie, and it's a goddamned delight.
I've come to appreciate Paul Thomas Anderson's other films, to varying degrees, but "Punch-Drunk Love" remains my favorite, probably because it's so declarative and unsubtle. We're meant to root for the guy to get the girl and stand up to the evil mattress salesman played by Philip Seymour Hoffman. We want to see red and blue come together, and for color to chase away the images of blank walls and empty gray streets. We want love to conquer all, and here it's allowed to. There are Anderson films with smarter writing, better performances, and more accomplished filmmaking, but "Punch-Drunk Love" has what I love most about movies, which is that it provokes a purity of emotion that you just don't get anywhere else.
What I've Seen - Paul Thomas Anderson
Hard Eight (1996)
Boogie Nights (1997)
Magnolia (1999)
Punch-Drunk Love (2002)
There Will Be Blood (2007)
The Master (2012)
Inherent Vice (2014)
Phantom Thread (2017)
Licorice Pizza (2021)
One Battle After Another (2025)
---