1. Hamnet - One of the things I prize most highly about the cinematic experience is its cathartic effect, and I had an emotional response to "Hamnet" like nothing else from last year. Yes, the movie is manipulative. However, it's very difficult to make an effective tearjerker, and playing on people's emotions is absolutely part of the assignment. The movie gives us a very human take on Shakespeare, and multiple opportunities for Jessie Buckley to bring down the house.
2. One Battle After Another - I have been struggling with how to rank "One Battle Another" against "Sinners" for the whole awards season. I have to give it to "One Battle," because the filmmaking is more ambitious and accomplished, the script is much denser with a lot of different themes packed in, and the characters are funnier in a way that not many films manage anymore. This is not my favorite of Paul Thomas Anderson's movies, but it might be his best one.
3. Sinners - On the other hand, you have to give "Sinners" its kudos for originality, for daring, and for the best soundtrack of the year, by far. The combination of so many different genres, tones, and cultural influences is irresistible, showing us the American South in the Prohibition era from not just one new perspective, but several. I want more stories from this universe, but I also want Ryan Coogler and Michael B. Jordan to continue to push in new directions.
4. Train Dreams - I wish I liked this better, because a film like "Train Dreams" doesn't get made very often. It's a period piece that does so much to evoke a past way of living that no longer exists, while still acknowledging the darker parts of that era. It's a film about the big questions in life, about a quiet man who is a bystander to history, and sees the world change in monumental ways. I appreciate its placidity - and yet I think it may have been too subtle for me at times.
5. Marty Supreme - Because this was such a tough watch for me, it never had a chance of placing higher. However, I strongly admire what Timothee Chalamet and Josh Safdie set out to do with the tale of Marty Mauser, ping-pong player and grifter supreme. The performances are fantastic, the scummy cinematography is absolutely gorgeous, the themes and writing are as good as anything I've ever seen out of the Safdies, and the laughs are well-earned.
6. Frankenstein - This is Guillermo Del Toro's "Frankenstein," not Mary Shelly's. And though Del Toro is prone to excesses, this is not a bad thing. Once you accept that this telling of the story is as much melancholic tragedy as cautionary horror story, it plays beautifully. Whatever you want to say about Jacob Elordi's Creature or Oscar Isaac's Victor, you're never going to mistake them for any of the other versions of the characters. And that's remarkable.
7. Sentimental Value - Honestly, this wasn't the kind of film that I was expecting from Joachim Trier and Renata Reinsve after their previous collaboration. Maybe it's because I much prefer "The Worst Person in the World" that I found "Sentimental Value" a little unsatisfying, despite it being a perfectly good film about the nature of art and artists and families. I enjoyed it while I was watching it, but I also retained very little, and haven't thought about it much since.
8. Secret Agent - I'm still grappling with this one. I really like some of Kleber Mendonca Filho's other films, but I'm running into the same problem that I did with "I'm Still Here," which is that I don't have the adequate frame of reference to absorb everything that's going on in this movie socially, culturally, and politically. And I think I need to. I just see a collection of fascinating pieces that I can't quite get to fit in a satisfactory way. I'm still not sure if it's me or the film.
9. Bugonia - So many parts of this Yorgos Lanthimos movie are great - the performances of Emma Stone and Jesse Plemmons, the Jerskin Fendrix score, and Robbie Ryan's breathtaking VistaVision cinematography, just to name a few. Unfortunately, for reasons I am still unpacking, the movie as a whole didn't work for me. I knew exactly where it was going far too quickly, and the nihilistic finale rubbed me the wrong way, despite being beautifully executed.
10. F1 - Well, this one's just lucky to be here. And there's absolutely no shame in being a well-made, perfectly entertaining blockbuster about fast cars that go zoom.
---