Clarence Brown is one of the less well-known directors of the Golden Age of Hollywood, who was very well regarded and respected in his time. He was nominated for the Best Director Oscar six times, and was a keen businessman who retired from filmmaking a rich man. He had a reputation as a star maker, having worked on the early films of Greta Garbo and Elizabeth Taylor, among others, and was generally well liked, despite being a notorious perfectionist.
I knew Brown's work mostly from his children's films - "National Velvet" and "The Yearling" were still in regular circulation when I was growing up. "The Yearling" in particular stuck with me, and I found that I frequently got the plot points mixed up with "Old Yeller," since they share many themes in common. And after watching so many other of Brown's films, it's still the ones featuring younger actors that I feel have the most to offer. These were often criticised for being maudlin, corny, and overly sentimental at the time that they were released, but they were so beautifully made and so earnest in their portrayal of big emotions, they became popular crowd-pleasers.
"The Yearling" is based on a novel by Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings, about a frontier family who have a farm in what is now the Ocala National Forest in Florida. The family's only surviving child, Jody, adopts an orphaned fawn despite the warnings of his father that he'll have to part with it when the fawn is grown. Brown's version of "The Yearling" was MGM's second attempt at an adaptation. The first, with director Victor Fleming, fell apart after the on-location shoot proved challenging, and a lead actor quit. A few years later, Brown brought in Gregory Peck and Jane Wyman to play the parents, and found 11 year-old Claude Jarman Jr. to play the lead. And he was able to shoot in many of the actual locations from the book, scouted for the production by Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings herself, who participated in the film as a consultant.
I don't think I've seen any film that better captures the physical and mental effort it took to survive life in the 1800s than "The Yearling." Threats to the family come in the form of a menacing bear, poisonous snakes, illness, injury, flooding, and starvation. The arrival of the fawn coincides with the death of Jody's only friend his own age, a young neighbor. In painstaking detail, it's then demonstrated to Jody why he can't keep his pet deer, Flag, once it's old enough to jump fences and target the family's precious crops. And yet, the bond between Jody and Flag is so poignant to witness, and the cruel end of their time together feels truly tragic. There is plenty of sentiment here, but also a hardscrabble realism and occasional brutality. The violent bear hunt sequence, notably, was shot before the American Humane Society had any real influence over the treatment of animals on film sets.
When I recently rewatched "The Yearling," I realized that I'd almost completely forgotten the presence of Gregory Peck. Jarman and Wyman's characters and their relationship were central to my memory of the film. I still think of Wyman onscreen as the cold, disapproving mother figure who has to be stern in order to keep both her and her child safe. After a few decades and having a few children of my own, I could finally appreciate her performance for being far more layered. The fear of showing love and the internal conflict is so evident in every scene. Peck as the kindly father is perfectly winning and well-considered - but still not very memorable.
The production endured no end of difficulties, with bouts of incessant rain, dozens of animals to wrangle, and a child actor who appeared in every scene, but was a total acting newcomer. Peck was splitting his time between "The Yearling" and "Duel in the Sun." However, Brown had been making movies for nearly three decades by this point, had adapted to the coming of sound and color, and he had the patience to persevere. He got what he wanted, even if it took up to thirty takes sometimes to get it.
And we got a movie that stands the test of time.
What I've Seen - Clarence Brown
The Eagle (1925)
The Goose Woman (1925)
Flesh and the Devil (1926)
The Trail of '98 (1928)
A Woman of Affairs (1928)
Anna Christie (1930)
A Free Soul (1931)
Anna Karenina (1935)
The Gorgeous Hussy (1936)
The Rains Came (1939)
Come Live with Me (1941)
The Human Comedy (1943)
National Velvet (1944)
The Yearling (1946)
Intruder in the Dust (1949)
---
No comments:
Post a Comment