Tuesday, January 31, 2023

Let's Talk About the New DC Slate

I debated over whether or not I should be posting anything about this list of projects so quickly, since we hardly know anything about the talent involved, most of the release dates, and of course half of these titles likely won't make it past the development stage.  James Gunn and Peter Safran are clearly ambitious, but we don't know how much they can deliver.


On the other hand, I count myself as more of a DC fan than a Marvel fan, and I've been waiting for an announcement like this for a while.  And it's big enough that I can definitely fill a whole post with just gut reactions.  Before I dive in, I want to point out how refreshing it is to have all this information delivered in such a straightforward manner, directly from James Gunn, and we didn't have to wade through all the excess of a convention or an investor call to get to the good stuff.   


Here we go:


"Creature Commandos" - An animated series written by James Gunn collecting some of the more offbeat DC characters (as if we'll ever run out) for a new team.  The Bride of Frankenstein and Weasel from "The Suicide Squad" are in the mix.  The plan is to introduce them as cartoons first, and then as live action.  This is already in production, so we'll probably see it relatively soon.  


"Waller" - A "Peacemaker" spinoff vehicle for Viola Davis, who will still be playing Amanda Waller for as long as she wants.  Obviously there have been no casting announcements yet for anyone else, but having a major black female character acting as a cornerstone of the new DCEU is a good move.  I hope we get some kind of origin story as part of this.  


"Lanterns" - DC struggled for ages to do something with "Green Lantern" in the wake of the disastrous 2011 film.  So, after years of trying to get a TV version off the ground, we're going to see Hal Jordan and John Stewart as space cops in a gritty crime drama.  If they do this right, it sounds like it could be a lot of fun.  But if they do this wrong, it's going to be ridiculous, and not in a good way.


"Paradise Lost" - First, I hope they change the title.  Second, this is the show that I'm the least convinced will actually become a show because the Amazons have never been terribly interesting or memorable characters.  "Game of Throne" style palace intrigue cannot be applied to everything, and we've had a solid decade of failed "Game of Thrones" wannabes already.  We need more details for this one.


"Booster Gold" -  I always liked Booster Gold in his few appearances in the "Justice League" cartoons.  He's a very everyman kind of character with a fantastic gimmick - he's a time traveler from the future who is using future tech to be a superhero.  Because he's otherwise a normal guy, the rest of the Justice League and many villains don't take him seriously.  But does he work without the Justice League?


"Swamp Thing" - We're trying this again?  We're trying this again.  


"Superman: The Legacy" - I'm not looking forward to another "Superman" movie - there have been too many bad ones in too short a span of time.  Gunn is keen to write and direct this one, and he seems to be signaling that he's going to take the opposite approach to the character from Zack Snyder, emphasizing kindness and humanity over any kind of dark power fantasies.  This is the most promising sign I've seen so far that Gunn hasn't forgotten that he has to aim some of these projects at a wider, PG-13 audience.    


"The Brave and the Bold" - I guess if you're going to do Robin, it kind of has to be Damian, doesn't it?  Jason and Tim were really just variations on Dick Grayson, but Damian is a completely different animal with an entirely different relationship to Batman.  Of all the announced film projects, this is the one I'm looking forward to the most, because it's going to make a big change to the cinematic Batman and we already know the new character works in other mediums.  Just don't screw up the casting, and we'll be fine.  


"The Authority" - I don't know much about "The Authority" except that it is a more adult-oriented title co-created by Warren Ellis and that it features one of the first major gay relationships of any prominence in DC's superhero books.  I suspect that this is the film most likely to stay in development for an extended period of time, but it's good to know that DC is giving these characters some attention.  


"Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow" - They're doing Tom King's Supergirl, who is very different from the versions of Supergirl we've seen so far - a tougher, more damaged heroine.  I suspect they'll soften her up a bit just so audiences won't be too taken aback, but this is a good pick.  It'll be "True Grit" in space, essentially, if they stick to the miniseries.  Fingers crossed that the fanboys will behave.


"The Batman" sequel and "Joker: Folie a Deux" - I can deal with them being treated as Elseworlds stories just as long as they're still getting made.


Overall, this slate is exactly what I would expect from James Gunn.  It's darker, edgier, and aimed at an older audience than the MCU.  It's a little strange seeing DC doing the riskier, more challenging, more subversive stories with their characters.  That's the role that Marvel used to have, pre MCU, when Batman and Superman were the old standbys.  It really is a new age, and I guess it's the right time.   


---

Sunday, January 29, 2023

All About "Andor"

Minor spoilers ahead.


"Andor" represents a major departure from the "Star Wars" content generated for Disney+ so far.  It's closest in spirit to the "Rogue One" film, which it serves as a prequel to, following the early career of resistance fighter Cassian Andor (Diego Luna).  This is a series aimed at an older audience, and is focused on the nuts and bolts of the Rebellion, just when it was getting started.  To that end, it's a much grimmer, talkier, murkier look at the "Star Wars" universe, full of echoes of real world conflicts.  It's also much larger in scope, with a first season that covers several different arcs - a getaway, a heist, and a prison break most prominently - while exploring the lives of major players on both sides of the conflict.


There are still plenty of action scenes and special effects in the series, but you won't see any lightsabers and Force users, and very few alien species.  Instead we have Rebel operative Luthen Rael (Stellan Skarsgård) who uses the front of a Coruscant antiques dealer while setting up dangerous missions secretly funded by Imperial Senator Mon Mothma (Genevieve O'Reilly).  We have Andor's home planet of Ferrix, where he lives with his adoptive mother Maarva (Fiona Shaw) and her droid B2EMO (Dave Chapman) under the increasingly hostile governance of the Empire.  Equally fascinating are the villains in the show, including a low level security guard, Syril Karn (Kyle Soller), who becomes obsessed with catching Andor, and Dedra Meero (Denise Gough), an ambitious Imperial security official who wants to move up in the Imperial bureaucracy.


While Andor is a charismatic figure, and Diego Luna is wonderful in the part, he's often not the most interesting character in the stories that play out over the course of the show.  Instead, he serves as an excellent everyman figure seeing all these different parts of the galaxy along with the audience.  One week, he and his friend Bix (Adria Arjona) are trying to figure out how to sell stolen equipment and leave the planet.  The next, he's on a heist with Rebel leader Vel Seltha (Faye Marsay) to steal an Imperial payroll.  And after that, he's quickly scooped up into a forced labor camp with Kino Loy (Andy Serkis) for multiple episodes.  Subplots follow Mon, Luthen, Syril, Dedra, and others.  We get a macroscopic view of how the Empire oppresses all these different people and planets, and a big part of Andor's character progression is how he eventually comes to the decision to join the Rebellion.


Like "Rogue One," "Andor" was created and largely written by Tony Gilroy, who is best known for the Jason Bourne movies and "Michael Clayton."  As a result, "Andor" feels less like the action adventure space fantasy that most "Star Wars" media has been and more like a dystopian allegory.  The characters are so much more nuanced and the choices they're faced with are often so much more complex that I can't see anyone under the age of twelve having much patience for this show.  Genevieve O'Reilly is one of the standouts as Mon Mothma, who has to delicately manage her political career and loveless marriage, while hiding the flow of money going to the Rebellion.  The Empire's atrocities are also much more chilling in a mundane and realistic way.   Early on, we learn that Andor was rescued as a child from his original home planet by Maarva, shortly before everyone on it was wiped out by an Imperial mining accident.


"Andor" is easily one of the best pieces of "Star Wars" media produced since the original film trilogy, and I'd like more in this vein.  It's nice to see all the resources that this franchise has at its disposal put in service of a story with more substance to it.  And frankly, it's a relief to find out that "Star Wars" works just fine without the Jedi and all their drama.  However, it would be a mistake for all of "Star Wars" to move in this direction, because the audience for it is necessarily more limited than something like "The Mandalorian."  "Andor" is already planned to stop after its next season, which will end right where "Rogue One" begins. 

---

Friday, January 27, 2023

All Hail "The Woman King"

The irony of "The Woman King" is that it pushes messages of African self-determination and the rejection of the evil influences of the West through the typical template of a Hollywood action spectacle.  It's a historical epic in the vein of movies like "Braveheart," "300," and "Gladiator," with the usual flouting of historical accuracy and gobs of engineered melodrama.  The difference is, of course, that "The Woman King" enters uncharted territory by applying the familiar formula to the female warriors, the Agojie, of the African Dahomey nation in the 1800s.


This means we get to see Viola Davis be an action star, and frankly I'm thrilled with the movie just for that.  She plays the Dahomey general, Nanisca, who leads the Agojie in a war against a larger kingdom, the Oyo, and their general, Oba Ade (Jimmy Odukoya).  She is also trying to convince Dahomey's new king, Ghezo (John Boyega), to end their kingdom's lucrative slave trade with the Portuguese.  We follow the action through the POV of a new recruit, Nawi (Thuso Mbedu), who joins the Agojie as hostilities with the Oyo are heating up.  Nawi trains under the Agojie warrior Izogie (Lashanna Lynch), and finds herself falling for a newly arrived mixed-race trader, Malik (Jordan Bolger) whose mother was from Dahomey.


The script has rightly weathered some criticism for seriously misrepresenting Dahomey's position with regard to the African slave trade.  In making the Agojie more palatable as heroes, their complicity has been almost totally erased.  I'm sure that the filmmakers could have made a much more historically accurate film that celebrated the existence of the Agojie in a  more nuanced fashion.  However, at some point the decision was made that the movie should be a crowd-pleasing adventure film, and director Gina Prince Bythewood spent the bulk of her efforts on making the action look good.  Whether or not you agree with this approach, the action scenes in "The Woman King" are absolutely beyond reproach.      

  

When it comes down to it, "The Woman King" is a genre film.  The story is pretty bare bones, using a few historical figures and a lot of well-worn tropes to put together a female empowerment and African empowerment narrative with a lot of exciting battle and fight sequences.  However, clearly great pains were put into the execution.  The costuming, the art direction, the cinematography, and the actors involved are all top notch.  I can't think of another Hollywood film that put this much effort into the onscreen presentation of any African kingdom, except, of course, Wakanda from "The Black Panther."  The influence of that film is all over this one, and I'm sure that its success is a major reason why "The Woman King" was greenlit.


Dahomey is not a place that many viewers in the West will be familiar with, so the filmmakers have to shorthand a lot of the customs and the culture.  I appreciate that not many things are outright explained, but you can mostly figure them out through the visuals.  The palace rituals and intrigues often reminded me of Japanese and Chinese costume dramas, while the training scenes clearly incorporate more modern military tactics.  It's unfortunate that the visual language caters so heavily to what Western viewers will be familiar with, but at the same time I was constantly seeing things onscreen that I'd never seen in a studio film before, and events depicted from African perspectives without compromise.  It shouldn't feel so novel, but it does.     


The cast delivers committed performances, especially the actresses playing the Agojie.   The scenes of warfare are breathtakingly visceral and violent, and surely required months of training to pull off.  However, they also do a great job of making their characters relatable human beings, despite often not having much to work with.  Davis and Lynch are the standouts, easily coming across as hardened, dangerous  warriors.  I'm so happy to see Thuso Mbedu here, who last appeared in "The Underground Railroad," with a very different role that allows her to be so much more active and lively as the hotheaded Niwa.  She holds her own in multiple scenes with Davis.   


I'm sure some viewers will be disappointed with "The Woman King" for not being the kind of representation that they were hoping for.  However, its biggest flaws are the ones that are endemic to all Hollywood historical epics.  The film is worth seeing as a piece of spectacle and presents a rare chance for many of these actresses to be the kind of action figure badasses that black women almost never get to be.  Along with movies like "Prey," 2022 has been a great year for shaking up the action movie status quo a bit.  I hope we get more movies like them.  


---

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

Your 2023 Oscar Nominees!


I don't know what I was expecting from this year's nominations, but this is quite a collection of movies.  The ten Best Picture nominations include the movies everyone has been acclaiming all year - "Everything Everywhere All At Once," "The Banshees of Inisherin," "The Fablemans," and "Tár," blockbuster hits "Avatar: The Way of Water," "Elvis," and "Top Gun: Maverick," and indies "Triangle of Sadness" and "Women Talking."  I didn't see "All Quiet on the Western Front" coming, edging out movies like "The Whale," "Babylon," "The Woman King," "Glass Onion," "RRR," and "Till" 


This was an unpredictable year for the Oscars, with no clear consensus on some of the major categories going into the announcements.  The wildest nomination is definitely Andrea Riseborough getting into Best Actress for "To Leslie," which I'd only heard about because the campaign for the little seen film  went viral.  She and Ana De Armas getting nominations meant Danielle Deadwyler and Viola Davis were left on the outs.  Bill Nighy and Paul Mescal getting nominations for Best Actor meant no Jeremy Pope.  Stephanie Hsu and Jamie Lee Curtis seem to have bumped Dolly DeLeon and Janelle Monet.


Frankly, it's not a good year for black cinema at the Oscars.  Brian Tyree Henry and Angela Bassett picked up acting nods in the Supporting Actor and Actress categories, but "The Woman King" and "Till" were totally shut out, while movies like "The Inspection," "Devotion," "Nope," "I Want to Dance With Somebody" and "Emancipation" never worked up much buzz.  Instead, Asian actors are all over the Acting categories, with Hong Chau finally getting a nod for "The Whale" along with four actors from "Everything Everywhere All At Once." 


It's also not a great year for women filmmakers.  "She Said" was snubbed, and "Women Talking" made it into the Best Picture race, but only had two nominations.  Sarah Polley didn't make it into the directing category as some had hoped.    As previously mentioned, women-led projects like "The Woman King" and "Till" got no attention.  My personal long shot for awards attention was "Good Luck to You Leo Grande," which did manage some acting nominations at the BAFTAs, but no such luck at the Oscars.    


I think that this is a very strong batch of movies overall, with no obvious duds like "Vice" in the mix.  Still, I'd written off a lot of these movies months ago, not having much enjoyed Ruben Ostlund's "Triangle of Sadness" or "All Quiet on the Western Front."  I feel I should write up reviews for these two, but frankly I don't have much to say about either of them.  I'm also not looking forward to sitting through "Avatar: The Way of Water," having cooled significantly on the original movie over the years.  It's the only major nominated film I haven't seen yet.  


There's something that feels off this year.  I don't understand how Ruben Ostlund is in the Best Director race.  What is "Top Gun: Maverick" doing in Best Adapted Screenplay?  And not Cinematography?! Where is "Decision to Leave"?  Or "Descendant?"  It's also odd to see Judd Hirsch in Best Supporting instead of Paul Dano.  Great performance, but if we want one-scene wonders from "The Fabelmans," why not David Lynch?  On the other hand, this is how I know that these awards aren't fixed.  These nominations are messy and weird, and reflect a movie industry that is much the same. 


If you'd told me that "Turning Red" would be the lone Disney/PIXAR nominee in the Best Animated Feature category at the beginning of the year, I would not have believed you.  If you'd told me that Tom Cruise not getting a Best Actor nod for "Top Gun: Maverick," would be considered a snub, I would have been doubtful.  Ehren Kruger being Oscar nominated is frankly depressing, but on the upside Ke Huy Quan is the frontrunner for Best Supporting Actor, with a comeback story for the ages.  I'm not really looking forward to Brendan Fraser turning on the waterworks again, but your mileage may vary.  


I still need some time to process this, and track down a few films.  With "Avatar" and "Top Gun: Maverick" in the mix, and Michael J. Fox getting the Hersholt, at least we're likely to see a bump in Oscar viewing figures.  At least we don't need to worry about that issue this year.


---

Monday, January 23, 2023

"His Dark Materials," Year Three

Spoilers for the first two series ahead.


It's a relief to come to the end of "His Dark Materials," which was always designed for a run of three series, and has suffered a rash of production troubles in trying to reach its conclusion.  I have never read the Philip Pullman books, and was looking forward to watching how the adaptation would play out without knowing anything about the story in advance.  I have no idea how closely the final season follows the "Amber Spyglass" novel, but it certainly feels like it's following a novel, with its sudden and seemingly arbitrary introduction of information, its embrace of big, conceptually difficult ideals, and its extended, fanciful denouement.


This is the season where we get into the material that made the religious folks so upset with the Pullman books - namely all the characters going to war against a rough stand-in for God.  It's made clear that the evil Metatron (Alex Hassell) is not actually the "Authority," but a usurper who has stolen his power and oppresses everyone who exists across all universes.  However, there's still the fear-and-damnation tactics of the Magisterium and its agents representing religion in general.  A big part of the season revolves around Will and Lyra journeying to the land of the dead to help the souls trapped there, including Roger and Will's father.  Meanwhile, several Angels have gotten involved in the conflict.  Xaphania (Chipo Chung) has allied forces with Asriel, while Balthamos (Kobna Holdbrook-Smith) and Baruch (Simon Harrison) help the children.  Mary Malone is off on a side quest in a world populated by sentient elephant-like creatures called mulefas, learning their language and their connection to Dust.  Finally, Mrs.  Coulter, still the most interesting player on the board, does her best to protect Lyra while remaining very dubious in her loyalties.


For a final culmination of all the storylines, with lots of returning characters and familiar faces (Hi Iorek!) this season is often remarkably slow and somber.  We get the big battles and the final confrontations, but these are rarely as exciting as you'd think.  There is a ton of interesting material to work through, and it sometimes feels like the writers are condensing huge amounts of information into very brief throwaway lines, without properly explaining concepts like The Authority and the Metatron and how the realm of the dead functions.  Solutions to problems, and the way things conclude often feel very arbitrary, especially the ending, which suddenly dumps a ton of new rules on us for how the universes are supposed to work.  And that's not unusual with children's books and fairy tales, but at the same time you'd think that the writers would try to spend a little more time setting things up and giving us context.  There always seems to be plenty of time for Asriel and Coulter to talk about Lyra, or for Lyra to talk about Roger, or for Will to talk about his father.  Good job making Mary Malone and the mulefas feel important, though I'm still not entirely clear on why.


While I still think that a serial is the best way of adapting this material, "His Dark Materials" probably should have been streamlined a bit to help keep the momentum up.  It's hard to argue that a story about challenging religious dogmas and remaking the afterlife should be more fun and accessible, but I really can't see many kids having the patience for this.  You can also tell that the show's budget isn't what it was.  The final battles barely involve any real action sequences, and the orchestral score is doing way too much of the heavy lifting.   For those who have been watching since the beginning, we do get several very satisfying payoffs to various storylines.  It's good to have James McAvoy a regular this year, if only to provide Ruth Wilson a consistently strong scene partner, and Asriel and Coulter get the best ending of anyone in the show.


I wish I could be as happy about Will and Lyra.  The two get a finale that frankly feels like it belongs to a different kind of story.  And I confess I looked up the relevant plot points from the book just to make sure it wasn't something that the show's writers had come up with on their own.  Maybe the final turn of events was something that was beyond the young actors, or maybe I was just caught off guard.  However, I'm still very grateful that we made it to the ending at all.  

  

Saturday, January 21, 2023

"White Lotus," Year Two

Minor spoilers ahead.


The second "White Lotus" miniseries takes place in Sicily, where another set of American tourists are forced to confront some uncomfortable truths about themselves while on vacation.  This year the focus isn't on the class divide, letting both the locals and the visitors get involved in stories revolving around love and sex, with varying outcomes.  


Our major characters include three groups of tourists, a very uptight White Lotus manager, Valentina (Sabrina Impacciatore), and a pair of ambitious prostitutes, Lucia (Simona Tabasco) and Mia (Beatrice Granno).  Tanya (Jennifer Coolidge) from the first series is back, with a new husband Greg (Jon Gries), and a new assistant, Portia (Haley Lu Richardson), in tow.  We also have two rich couples, Harper (Aubrey Plaza) and Ethan (Will Sharpe), and Cameron (Theo James) and Daphne (Meghann Fahy), with very different outlooks on matrimony.  Finally, there are the three generations of the Di Grasso family, who are in Italy to search for their roots - grandfather Bert (F. Murray Abraham), father Dominic (Michael Imperioli), and son Albie (Adam DiMarco).  The prostitutes are our main linking characters, appearing in each story.


Like the first season, we have gorgeous locales, an incredibly talented cast, and a lot of pointed skewering of the little hypocrisies that everyone employs.  Mike White has a lot of fun taking aim at different aspects of his subject matter through the various characters.  The couples are his way to talk about fidelity and jealousy.  The Di Grassos embody generational differences in attitudes toward sex - and how none of that ultimately matters. Valentina is our example of what happens when sexuality is denied.  Tanya and Portia are both blinded by love, ultimately taking them to very unexpected places.  Lucia and Mia treat sex as purely transactional and are the least troubled characters of the lot.  They're the ones who understand best that anybody can be seduced, and perhaps on some level everyone wants to be.  The dark comedy is less biting this year, and there are several happy - or at least less downbeat endings.


This makes the season more watchable, but also significantly tamer than the first.  There are no truly hateable characters, no deeply uncomfortable topics being broached, and it's only in the last episode that anything truly intense and shocking happens.  The performances are good all around, with a notably higher caliber cast, but I didn't find anything on the level of Murray Barlett's work in the Hawaii season.  Jennifer Coolidge comes close, though.  Still, the writing remains very strong, and often very funny.  I think it was a good choice to have several potentially calamitous situations foreshadowed that never actually happen, and a lot of things are left open ended and ambiguous.  This is one of those shows that's probably best to watch live, because speculating how events will play out is half the fun.  


My biggest disappointment with the season is that some of the actors, like F. Murray Abraham, stayed on the sidelines and didn't have much to do.  Michael Imperioli has a promising storyline set up that doesn't really go anywhere.  There's also the fact that the White Lotus hotel staff are a smaller part of this season, with Valentina's story being fairly limited, and never affecting any of the guests.  On the other hand, I can see why Mike White would want to avoid setting the expectation that every season would have to involve the hotel staff.  Not all the White Lotuses should be as dysfunctional as the one in the first series.  


I'm looking forward to the next round, which White has already hinted will be about death.  Well, it will be about death more directly than the show has been so far.  There are also a couple of loose ends left here that it would be such a shame to not see the fallout from next season.  Until next time.

---

Thursday, January 19, 2023

My Top Ten Episodes of "Westworld"

In the end, HBO's "Westworld" ran for 36 episodes over six years.  There are ongoing arguments over the relative quality of the four seasons, but I enjoyed it the whole way through.  And though the creators might have planned a fifth season, I don't find one necessary.  The cold, ambiguous finale is a perfectly suitable way to close out a very difficult, often impenetrable show.  I know I didn't understand what was going on half of the time, but I admire Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy's ambitions, and a lot of good work by talented cast and crew members.


The episodes below are unranked and ordered by airdate.  Spoilers ahead.


"The Original" - The series premiere was an event, showing off this new universe full of sinister robot "hosts" and the even more sinister human beings behind them.  Characters are introduced, the rules of the game are announced, and then we get to watch the fantasy grow darker and darker.  The line between the hosts and the guests is already blurry, and the show is already playing with time and memory to good effect.  And has the swatting of a fly ever been more portentous?     


"Tromp L'Oeil" - A big turning point episode for the first season that reveals Bernard is a host, with one of the great lines of the series - "It doesn't look like anything to me."  This is also the episode where Maeve finagles her way into Operations and menaces Sylvester and Felix, Dr. Ford reveals himself as a Bigger Bad than he'd let on, and Theresa ends up dead.  The first season was great at building up tension and juggling tones, and this is a great example for both.  What did happen to Sylvester and Felix?  


"The Bicameral Mind" - The finale of season one had a big reveal that many fans managed to work out weeks ahead of time, but I thought that it still had plenty of impact.  Several characters reach big, decisive moments as the massacre we've been waiting for all season finally takes place. The death of Dr. Ford is a highlight, and I still find it hard to believe that we had Anthony Hopkins as a regular on this show, even if it was only for one season.  He certainly proved impossible to replace.  


"The Riddle of the Sphinx" - I haven't talked about Ed Harris and the Man in Black yet, who is the show's most memorable human character.  Here, we delve into his history and his family ties, especially his relationship with his father-in-law, James Delos.  The fidelity trials are some of the most fascinating and horrific bits of science fiction we see in the show.   Ed Harris and Peter Mullan both deliver unnerving performances, especially when it's revealed what happened to the rest of the Delos clan.


"Akane no Mai" - It's too bad that we didn't spend more time in the Eastern version of the Westworld park.  The show got Rinko Kikuchi and Hiroyuki Sanada, and clearly spent considerable resources to create their Japanese village and outfit all the samurai.  The repeated musical cues, echoing the series premiere, are especially fun.  However, the MVP here is Thandiwe Newton.  She's always been one of the standouts in the cast, and here she's juggling Japanese dialogue and a lot of action scenes beautifully.  


"Kiksuya" - The best episode of the series gives us a look at this universe from the point of a background character, Akecheta, played by Zahn McClarnon.  Their tribe may be fictional, but there's still a strong sense of authenticity to the experience of the Native American characters in this episode, who try to make sense of Westworld from a very different cultural context.  McClarnon's performance, a Nirvana cover, and stellar direction contribute to some of the show's most arresting moments.   


"The Passenger" - Though highly convoluted, the second season ends in a satisfying way, with many of the hosts escaping into the Sublime, and a few others making their way into the outside world.  The extended ninety minute running time, the convergence of so many stories, and the another round of big reveals and new mysteries make this too much of a good thing at times.  However, it's a great farewell to the park, and the post-credits sequence is one of the show's greatest cliffhangers.


"The Absence of Field" - Tessa Thompson took on a more central role in the later seasons, when Dolores decided to use a Charlotte Hale host body and killed the original.  Here, we see the Hale host struggling to reconcile her AI existence with the life of the human being she has replaced - both ultimately influencing her path forward.  Meanwhile, the Rehoboam story with Dolores and Caleb is rolling along, which I seem to like better than most viewers, especially the way it treats the idea of predestination.  


"Generation Loss" - Just when you thought that the fourth season was going to be relatively straightforward, it's revealed that we've been watching asynchronous timelines yet again.  I thought the fourth season was actually better than the previous two in many ways, especially the AI-run dystopia that it presents, inverting the original premise.  Hale makes for an excellent villain, and Caleb is a far more sympathetic protagonist than anyone else in the series, and worth rooting for.


"Fidelity" - Finally, this episode doesn't quite share the same premise as the 2009 horror movie "Triangle," but it shares a lot of the nightmare imagery, as Hale creates multiple copies of Caleb to interrogate, who quickly become a pile of corpses littering the latest version's escape route.  It's a terrifically dark scenario that builds on the existential horror of "Riddle of the Sphinx," and gives Aaron Paul a chance to give a really memorable performance.  


---