There's a lot going on in Wednesday's life this year. Her brother Pugsley (Isaac Ordonez) is joining her at Nevermore Academy, which means her parents are intent on sticking around in close proximity for most of the season. There's a new Nevermore principal, a suspicious fellow named Barry Dort (Steve Buscemi). There's a new music teacher, Isadora Capri (Billie Piper), also suspicious. Wednesday attracts an obsessive fangirl, Agnes (Evie Templeton), with boundary issues. Bodies start turning up, characters from last season are still lurking around (even the dead ones), and the only friend Pugsley is able to make is a zombie he accidentally creates and names Slurp (Owen Painter). Even worse, Wednesday has lost her psychic powers and Enid is under threat.
The first season of "Wednesday" was a smash hit for Netflix, and suddenly it feels like everyone wants to be on the show. Catherine Zeta-Jones and Luis Guzman, who only appeared previously as recurring characters, are now series regulars. There are big names playing all the guest stars, no matter how minor the part. Hey, it's Thandiwe Newton running a mental asylum! Hey, it's Christopher Lloyd as a disembodied head! Characters from the first season who really have no reason to be in the second show up anyway. Sometimes this is great, like Gwendolyn Christie popping up as Wednesday's exasperated new spirit guide, and sometimes this is just a distraction. It feels like there's also an obligation to repeat all the hits - an Uncle Fester episode, a dance sequence, more cello playing and more fencing. However, this season rarely gives Wednesday enough breathing room to attempt any character growth or to even check in on the friendships that were central to the show the last time we saw it.
It takes much longer than it should for "Wednesday's" second season to find its footing. Frankly, the first half is an unappealing jumble of too many characters with too many problems all vying for our attention. Wednesday herself comes off as unnecessarily mean and antagonistic instead of a classic outcast, since most of her schoolmates are cool with her now. The family drama feels forced and there aren't any decent villains for far too long. Eventually the show gets back on track, in part because the focus shifts from Wednesday obsessing over her own agendas to Wednesday helping her friends - Enid, Agnes, Bianca, Tyler and even Thing - who give us more sympathetic protagonists to root for. Eventually all those disparate stories do come together, if you have the patience to make it to the end. However, it relies on an awful lot of coincidences and messy reveals - and there are loose ends left everywhere.
Tim Burton is back to direct half of the episodes and Netflix's pockets are deep when it comes to their hits, so we get a lot of fancy set pieces, CGI creature transformations, and even a brief stop-motion animation sequence in the premiere. However, the most fun comes from relatively simple character business like a body-switch scenario and Joanna Lumley's snootier take on the Addams' Grandmama. "Wednesday" features an Addams family with very different dynamics than the previous ones we've seen in other Addams media, and I'm all for it. The show's larger worldbuilding, however, where anyone with powers is some kind of "misfit," subject to all manner of arbitrary rules, had me rolling my eyes. We just have to call mad scientists "Da Vincis," and there happens to be a special subclass of werewolves called "Alphas" that are both super strong and super vulnerable.
Then again, I'm older and far more cynical than the intended audience for this show. This is, after all, a YA horror fantasy set at a magic boarding school. I don't think that the younger fans of "Wednesday" will have any problems with the new season. As for me, I liked enough of it that I'll keep watching, with the hope that Burton and company will cut the cast list down to size next time.
---