Back in 2012, one of the films
on my "to watch" list at the end of the year was Ava DuVernay's "Middle
of Nowhere," a domestic drama starring Sharon Lawrence and David
Oyelowo that had gotten a good amount of critical acclaim. I waited for
it to appear on DVD the following year. And waited. And waited. And
I'd probably still be waiting if DuVernay and Oyelowo's follow-up
project wasn't the excellent historical drama, "Selma," chronicling the
actions of American Civil Rights campaigners in 1964. The film is
currently attracting controversy, but I'm worried that its well-deserved
status as an awards contender is going to keep people from seeing it.
And
boy, do I hope that people see this one. I understand why some
audiences are approaching with caution. It's got all the earmarks
of the kind of unbearably self-serious, one-note historical prestige pic
that's been far too prevalent this season. Oprah Winfrey, who has been
associated with some of the more misguided entries into this genre (see
Lee Daniels' recent work), is prominent as one of film's producers and
has a small supporting role. But those who would write off "Selma"
sight unseen are going to miss one of the best films about the Civil
Rights movement and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. ever made. Heck, they're
going to miss one of the best films of 2014 period.
There
are many similarities between "Selma" and Steven Spielberg's recent
"Lincoln." It takes the approach of dramatizing one important chapter
in its subject's life, in this case the protests that took place in
Selma, Alabama for voting rights. Dr. King, played by Oyelowo,
is brought down to earth, portrayed as a man with great flaws and great
doubts who has to balance multiple competing interests. The script is
very literate and avoids hand-holding, assuming viewers are already
broadly familiar with major players like Dr. King and Governor Wallace
and events like the bombing of the16th Street Baptist Church that
brought the movement to Selma. Oyelowo's performance is tremendous,
easily anchoring the whole project, and backed up by a great ensemble
led by Carmen Ejogo as Coretta Scott King, Tom Wilkinson as President
Lyndon B. Johnson, and Tim Roth as Governor George Wallace.
However, "Selma"
is fundamentally different from "Lincoln" in that it's concerned
primarily with the movement rather than an individual. Though it uses
him as a focal point, the film resists the urge to become a biopic of
Dr. King, instead taking pains to shine the spotlight on smaller figures
involved in the campaign, including white supporters. "Selma" explores
Dr. King's role as a strategist and negotiator, careful to treat him
as a man rather than an icon, and it extends this attitude to the
rest of the major players as well. President Johnson is portrayed as a
sympathetic ally, but one who has to be prodded into action - a
portrayal which has made some of his supporters uncomfortable. Then
there are the other participants in the Civil Rights Movement,
representing multiple factions and ideologies and interests. There are
far too many to identify and do justice to all of them - many important
figures who show up onscreen aren't even named - but as they plan and
debate and coordinate, we get a glimpse of how the movement operated day
to day, on the ground, in the thick of it.
Dr.
King is absent for many of the important events in "Selma," so our
attention shifts to Hosea Williams (Wendell Pierce) or Jimmie Lee
Jackson (Keith Stanfield) or others. Eventually our investment is with
the Civil Rights movement, as it should be, rather than any particular
individual. At one point near the end of the film, we suddenly get a
scene with Cuba Gooding Jr. and Martin Sheen playing an attorney and a
judge. Neither of their characters are identified, but it quickly
becomes apparent that Gooding's character is handling a legal
challenge to allow the march from Selma to Montgomery. The narrative is
so clear, and the momentum of the unfolding events so strong, that
little cutaways and digressions like this are possible, and the director
takes full advantage.
And speaking of the
director, I'm glad to report that "Middle of Nowhere" was finally
released on DVD and all the usual streaming platforms last week. I
doubt that it'll match up to "Selma," which is as impressive a
historical film as I've ever seen, but it's nice to finally have access
to the work of a black female director who has certainly proven worth
paying more attention to.
---