I suspect that "Wake Up Dead Man" is the best Rian Johnson film. It's easily the best of the three Benoit Blanc movies he's made so far, and I really liked the first two. "Wake Up Dead Man" is another murder mystery featuring the Daniel Criag sleuth, with plenty of social commentary, and some good laughs in the mix. However, this is a darker, more thoughtful story, set in and around a small Catholic church in upstate New York. The new assistant pastor, Father Jud (Josh O'Connor) has written to Benoit Blanc about a murder. Who the victim is probably counts as a spoiler, so I'll just say that the major figures involved in the crime are the charismatic firebrand Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), his henchwoman Martha (Glenn Close), her husband Samson (Thomas Hayden Church), and local townsfolk played by Jeremy Renner, Kerry Washington, Andrew Scott, Daryl McCormack, Mila Kunis and Cailee Spaeny.
Unlike "Knives Out" and "Glass Onion," the rich aren't the targets of "Wake Up Dead Man." Rather, we're looking at a different facet of privilege and power, with religion put under the microscope. Christianity is examined from several different points of view, with Monsignor Wicks and Father Jud each offering their own contrasting viewpoints. Benoit Blanc is the skeptical atheist who comes on the scene trying to find the truth, and it's a much more complicated story than it seems at first glance, touching on a lot of the different roles that Christianity and the church play in American society. The only way to solve the mystery is to understand the worldviews of the suspects, and the lesson, ultimately, is the importance of empathy rather than faith. Rian Johnson has described himself as an ex-believer in interviews, and you can absolutely tell how personal this material is to him. There are some very funny scenes and suitably sharp zingers, but Johnson is also earnestly grappling with questions of how religion fits into the modern world, in a way that only someone very familiar with the church could.
"Wake Up Dead Man" benefits from a very strong cast. The clear standout is Josh O'Connor, who has the tricky job of staying both sympathetic and untrustworthy in the minds of the viewers for most of the movie. He has the vast majority of the screentime, and I find it very meaningful that he struggles honestly and openly with his role at the church in a way that feels far too rare. Unfortunately, this means that the rest of the cast feel less well served. Or rather, the other characters feel broad and caricatured the way that the characters in "Knives Out" and "Glass Onion" were, but few display the depth and the shadings that Father Jud does. Wicks, for instance, is memorably vile, and I admire Brolin's performance, but I was never able to quite take him seriously as a threat to our heroes, and he wasn't outrageously nasty enough to be as entertaining as he could have been. Actors like Andrew Scott and Kerry Washington barely have enough screen time for their characters to register, though they're good enough actors that they do. Glenn Close, however, finally gets a role worthy of her talents in who knows how long.
Johnson gets a lot of great imagery out of the ecclesiastical trappings, and the visual storytelling is consistently excellent. I love the local bar that's devil themed, and Father Jud's tattoos hinting at a past that can't be easily erased. The running gag with Martha is pitch perfect every time it happens. The editing is fabulous, deftly juggling the multiple POVs and jumps to different points on the timeline. This is a long movie, and the investigation doesn't really get underway until Blanc shows up around 45 minutes in, but it never feels too slow or too indulgent. Okay, Rian Johnson probably wouldn't have gotten away with some of the more venal jokes if this were the first Benoit Blanc movie, but he's earned some leeway from me.
Most importantly, the story feels fully explored and the tone is well balanced. All the little things that used to bother me about Rian Johnson films have been addressed, or are compensated for. This is the first film of his I'm comfortable calling a great film, and it's timely, entertaining, and genuinely moving too. If this is the last Benoit Blanc film, the series is going out on a high note. And it's leaving me wanting more.
---