I'm so glad that body horror movies are coming back into vogue, and that we're getting some really interesting female body horror movies specifically. "The Ugly Stepsister," the first film from Norwegian writer/director Emilie Blichfeldt, is everything I want from this kind of movie. It's a subversion of a familiar fairy tale narrative that takes the opportunity to aim a few blows at terrible female beauty standards, toxic family dynamics, and false idols. Also, the performances are very effective and the gore is really gross.
"The Ugly Stepsisters" is built around one very good idea: "Cinderella" from the point of view of the stepsisters is a horror story. Blichfeldt uses the original Brothers Grimm version of "Cinderella," with all the gruesome bits about how to get a foot to fit into a tiny glass shoe, as her starting point. Plain Elvira (Lea Myren) is the older daughter of the ambitious Rebekka (Ane Dahl Torp), who marries a man named Otto (Ralph Carlsson) for his money. Alas, Otto drops dead almost immediately, leaving Rebekka with debts instead of riches, and a new stepdaughter, the beautiful Agnes (Thea Sofie Loch Næss). After learning that the local prince (Isac Calmroth) wants a bride, Elvira and Agnes become rivals for his attention.
Watching Elvira destroy herself in the pursuit of beauty and the false hope of a happy ending is like watching a magnificently orchestrated car crash. The physical horrors of the barbaric beauty treatments that Rebekka pushes on her are bad enough, but the real damage is caused by Elvira's growing resentment toward the effortless physical perfection of Agnes and an increasingly anxious fixation on besting her. While the original "Cinderella" story plays out it full over the course of the film, here it's on the margins of Elvira's miserable tale of endless suffering and disappointment. Its perfect fairy-tale moments linger just out of her grasp as a half-hallucinatory ideal that she desperately wants to attain. Instead, she has to contend with months of starving herself, a beautician that wields a chisel and hammer, and dancing instruction that doubles as ritual humiliation. And the film makes it clear that through her choices, she brings much of her misfortune on herself.
Some interesting shadings are also added to the other characters for some additional nuance. Agnes is neither pure nor good - she doesn't love the prince and only wants him to get herself out of a bad situation. She antagonizes Rebekka and Elvira as much as they antagonize her. Elvira's younger sister Alma (Flo Fagerli) is too young for marriage, and she has no interest in the prince or her mother's machinations. She's a lone voice of reason in the film that Elvira chooses to ignore. Rebekka is the terrible stepmother we all expect, but more self-interested than malicious. Her choices are few and she has to be pragmatic. Then there's the prince, who Elvira has fallen in love with via a volume of his published poems. A chance encounter with him early in the film reveals that he's a venal boor, but Elvira is so lovesick that this doesn't dissuade her at all.
For lovers of body horror, there are several impressive sequences of squirm-inducing nastiness. One involves self-mutilation. Another involves tapeworms. The worst for me, however, was a brutal cosmetic surgery procedure that went from zero to off the charts terrifying in seconds. Due to the themes and the genre, there are some similarities to last year's "The Substance," but "The Ugly Stepsister" is playing with different tropes and ideas. I found the production very impressive. The film was made on a modest budget, but it never feels like any corners are being cut due to skillful filmmaking. The performers also deserve no small amount of credit. Lea Myren does much of the heavy lifting in Elvira's transformations from unfortunate frump to rising ingenue to damaged monster.
I've always had a fondness for dark fairy tale films, and this is definitely one of the darkest and most satisfying. It reminds me of something I might have stumbled across in the '80s, especially the way the gore is so stylized and achieved mostly with practical effects work. They manage to make eyelashes in this movie sinister, and it's fantastic. In short, horror fans, this is not one to miss.
---